The Best Thrift Store Chains Ranked by Value and Selection
1123
Thrift Stores Listed
4.2
Average Rating
How We Ranked These Thrift Stores
There’s no fluff here. We judged these chains using four practical, no-nonsense criteria:- Value: Are the prices good? Do they run regular sales or promotions? Can you walk out with a cartload for under $20?
- Selection: Variety matters. Clothing, furniture, housewares, books, do they have a good mix, or are they just racks of stained T-shirts?
- Customer Feedback: People are vocal online, and we looked at what shoppers are saying. Stores with strong reviews scored higher.
- Availability: Nationwide reach or local favorite? Chains with more locations obviously make it easier for everyone to shop.
The Top Thrift Store Chains (Ranked)
1. Goodwill
Let’s not pretend this wasn’t going to be #1. With over 3,200 locations across the U.S., Goodwill is basically the McDonald’s of thrift shopping (but in a good way). You know exactly what you’re getting: a mix of affordable clothing, household items, furniture, and even some electronics if you’re lucky. Value: Prices are generally reasonable, but it depends on the location. Some stores have a reputation for marking up items that shouldn’t cost more than $3. On the flip side, their color tag discounts (up to 50% off) are a lifesaver. Selection: Huge variety. You could find a barely used designer blazer and a retro toaster in the same aisle. The quality can be hit or miss, but when it’s good, it’s really good. Availability: They’re everywhere. If you live in the U.S., odds are there’s a Goodwill within driving distance. One weird quirk? The prices on certain items (like plain mugs or picture frames) can vary wildly between locations. Not a dealbreaker, but it’s worth keeping in mind. ---2. The Salvation Army
Salvation Army stores have been around forever. And while they aren’t as flashy as some other chains, they’re consistent. Value: Very competitive pricing, especially on furniture. You can snag a solid wood dining table for less than what you’d pay for a new IKEA one. Selection: They focus heavily on clothing and furniture, but you’ll also find random treasures like vintage records or quirky wall art. They’re also a good spot for winter coats, seriously, don’t sleep on their coat racks. Availability: Over 1,200 locations in the U.S. Not as many as Goodwill, but still plenty of options. One downside: their stores can feel a bit cluttered. It’s not always an “easy browse” experience. ---3. Savers (or Value Village)
If you’re looking for a slightly “fancier” thrift store, this is it. Savers leans into the curated vibe, which means their prices can be higher. Value: You’re paying for the curation here. Prices are higher than Goodwill or Salvation Army, but the trade-off is you’re less likely to sort through junk. Selection: A+ for quality. Their clothing racks feel like a mix between a department store and a second-hand shop. They often carry name brands and items that feel new. Availability: Around 300 locations in the U.S. and Canada. Not huge, but they’re in major metro areas. Pro tip: If you’re hunting for a very specific item (like a formal dress), this is the place to go.
4. Plato’s Closet
For teens and young adults, Plato’s Closet is a no-brainer. This chain specializes in trendy, gently used clothing from brands like Hollister, American Eagle, and Urban Outfitters. Value: Prices are higher than your average thrift store, but still much cheaper than retail. If you’re looking for name brands at 70% off, this is the spot. Selection: Clothing only. They focus on trendy, current styles, so don’t expect to find grandma’s vintage couch here. Availability: Over 475 locations across North America. Most stores are franchise-owned, so quality can vary. ---5. Buffalo Exchange
This chain is for the fashion-forward crowd. If you love vintage or unique statement pieces, Buffalo Exchange is your thrift heaven. Value: Definitely on the pricier side, but worth it if you’re after quality and style. They also let you trade in clothes for store credit. Selection: Smaller stores, but very curated. You’re paying for the vibe and the quality of the pieces. Availability: Just 50 locations in 17 states. Not as widespread, but worth a visit if there’s one nearby. ---Honorable Mentions: Local and Regional Favorites
Sometimes the best spots aren’t chains at all. Places like ARC Thrift Stores in Colorado or Deseret Industries in Utah are regional favorites that compete with the big names. They offer strong community ties, great prices, and unique finds. Want to explore more budget-friendly options? Check out salvage grocery stores near you for another way to save big on essentials. ---Thrift Shopping by the Numbers
Here’s a quick look at some data from the Thrift Store Pal directory:| Top Businesses | City | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Dirtbag Vintage | Fayetteville, AR | 5.0 stars (538 reviews) |
| Gift To Earth Thrift Store | South Plainfield, NJ | 5.0 stars (354 reviews) |
| Tandem Vintage | Minneapolis, MN | 5.0 stars (169 reviews) |
FAQs About Thrift Store Shopping
How often should I visit thrift stores?
Go as often as you can! New inventory comes in daily, and the best stuff gets snatched up fast.
Are thrift stores really cheaper than buying new?
Yes, but it depends on the store. Chains like Goodwill and Salvation Army are much cheaper than buying retail.
