Jay's Unique Thrift Store
Closed
About Jay's Unique Thrift Store
Jay's Unique Thrift Store in Questa, NM, offers a diverse selection of secondhand items, including clothing, furniture, tools, vinyl records, and even unique collectibles. It's a great spot for anyone looking to score a bargain or find something one-of-a-kind.
The atmosphere at Jay's is warm and welcoming, thanks to the friendly family owners who are eager to help you find what you're looking for. Shoppers often mention that browsing through the eclectic mix of items feels like a treasure hunt.
Conveniently located in Questa, this thrift store is easily accessible with ample parking available nearby. Whether you're a local or just passing through, it's a charming stop to explore.
Editor's Review
Jay's Unique Thrift Store in Questa, NM, boasts an impressive overall rating of 4.6 out of 5, based on 66 reviews. This high score reflects a strong consensus among customers who appreciate the eclectic mix of items available. As Rhonda Mc noted, 'They have some really cool stuff in here.' Many reviews highlight the store's variety, with products ranging from books and furniture to tools and vinyl records. Mary Patricia endorsed its diverse inventory, mentioning that 'they have everything from tools, vinyl, furniture, clothes, rocks, etc.'
One standout feature is the welcoming atmosphere fostered by owner Jay, who receives consistent praise for his friendliness and approachability. Andy Bratz described the store as 'family-owned and operated, very nice and welcoming people.' This warm customer service might be one reason people feel inclined to return.
While the overall feedback leans positive, some reviewers hint at limitations. A notable concern is the ever-changing inventory. Though many see it as a positive, the frequent turnover means that customers may not always find what they're looking for on each visit. Christy Lujan pointed out that 'whoever left bad reviews were wrong,' emphasizing that inventory changes often. This could be a double-edged sword for those seeking specific items.
What We Like
- Diverse inventory with a wide range of unique items
- Friendly and welcoming atmosphere, particularly from owner Jay
- Consistently changing stock encourages repeat visits
Room for Improvement
- Frequent inventory turnover may lead to limited availability of specific items
- Some customers found it hard to find exactly what they wanted
What Customers Are Saying
“'They have some really cool stuff in here.'”
— Rhonda Mc
“'Every time we visit the area Jay's is a MUST stop.'”
— James Wagner
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“They have everything from tools, vinyl, furniture”
“More great prices! We love this store!”
“very nice and welcoming people”
“Such a cool unique store!”
Insider Tips
Visit after holidays for new inventory
Bring kids for a fun experience
What to Expect
- Expect a friendly shopping experience with helpful staff ready to assist you.
- You'll find a wide range of unique secondhand items, from practical tools to fun collectibles.
- Prices are generally very reasonable, making it a great place to find value.
Google Reviews
They have some really cool stuff in here. I enjoyed looking through everything. I bought several books and an electrical cord to replace one that had broken on my electric hot water pot.
Found a few cool things here. Family owned and operated, very nice and welcoming people.
Such a cool unique store! They have everything from tools, vinyl, furniture, clothes, rocks, etc. They’re extremely friendly and will make a deal for you! Will definitely be back next time I’m in town!
This IS a Unique place. Went before Christmas and bought a lot, anxious to go back and they just opened up from the holidays. Lot of new stuff, bought more! Great place, very nice owner! It's now February and went again. More new stuff! More great p...
Everytime we visit the area Jay's is a MUST stop. He's a great guy, prices fairly, usually off the cuff which is fun. He is constantly changing out his inventory so you never know what you will find. He's also great with kids, our four year old loves...
Reviews from Google
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
Be sure to take your time and explore all the nooks and crannies of the store to find hidden gems.
Visiting on a Wednesday is your best bet, as it's the only day they're open.
There's easy parking available nearby, so don't worry about finding a spot.
Hours
- mondayClosed
- tuesdayClosed
- wednesday11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- thursday11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- friday8:00 AM - 6:00 PM
- saturday11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- sundayClosed