The Lighthouse Thrift Store
Closed
About The Lighthouse Thrift Store
The Lighthouse Thrift Store in Columbus, WI, offers a variety of secondhand items, making it a great stop for anyone looking to score unique finds. With a well-stocked inventory, shoppers can expect to discover everything from clothing to household goods at this local favorite.
When you step inside, you'll find a friendly atmosphere where items are neatly organized, making it easy to browse. Although some visitors have mentioned concerns about pricing and quality, many still appreciate the opportunity to find hidden treasures amidst the selection.
Conveniently located in Columbus, the store is accessible for both locals and visitors. Whether you’re driving or walking, you’ll appreciate the inviting setup that encourages exploration.
Editor's Review
At The Lighthouse Thrift Store, the buzz around town is certainly mixed. Some visitors rave about the treasures they’ve found, while others express disappointment regarding pricing. As Corinne Winter shared, 'I always seem to find treasures here!' This store keeps its inventory fresh, with a full back room of items waiting to be tagged and put out for eager shoppers. Yet, not everyone feels the same sense of delight.
Several reviewers, like Victoria Pogue, point out that prices seem to have crept higher, making even common items like Tupperware feel overpriced. 'Tupperware that was just normal in size were 8+ dollars,' she noted, contrasting this with the affordable prices typically found at Goodwill. While the store is praised for its organization and friendly staff, reviewer Katina Theodozio felt let down by the overall quality and pricing, saying it felt more like a 'liquidator profit zone.'
Despite the varied experiences, it’s clear that The Lighthouse Thrift Store has something for everyone if you’re willing to look. For some, it’s a nostalgic trip to the glory days of thrifting; for others, it might be just an average thrift store experience.
What We Like
- Friendly and helpful staff
- Well-stocked inventory with new items regularly
- Organized layout makes shopping enjoyable
Room for Improvement
- Inconsistent pricing, with some items considered overpriced
- Mixed reviews on the quality of products
- Some electronics may not be tested before sale
What Customers Are Saying
“'They are definitely well stocked and I always see a full back room waiting to be tagged and brought out so it’s new stuff every day.'”
— Corinne Winter
“'Very friendly, very reasonably priced, very honest if something’s broken or chipped.'”
— Cinder Roeder
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“Prices have been outrageously high”
“Dirty and very poor quality items”
“I always seem to find treasures here!”
“Customer Service was also great, kind and helpful”
Insider Tips
Visit frequently for new stock
Check prices against other thrift stores
What to Expect
- You'll enjoy a well-organized space that makes shopping feel easy and enjoyable.
- Expect to find a variety of secondhand items, perfect for those looking for unique pieces or bargains.
- While some items may be on the pricier side, many shoppers feel they offer good value compared to other thrift stores.
Google Reviews
Dirty and very poor quality items with most over priced for value. This is not a thrift store, but more of a liquidator profit zone. Although the store items are nicely organized and staff were friendly, I was hugely disappointed and will not be retu...
I always seem to find treasures here! Prices are better than Goodwill there’s quite a bit to look at. They are definitely well stocked and I always see a full back room waiting to be tagged and brought out so it’s new stuff every day.
This place used to be my favorite place. The one and only true thrift store left around- with prices that matched today’s inflation and didn’t act like an antique store. The last 3 times I’ve gone the prices have been outrageously high- higher than g...
I thought it was pretty unfortunate for this store to have the 1 previous review it did. I decided to give them a shot anyway, and was thoroughly pleased with my experience. Thought things were priced very reasonable (better than Goodwill). Customer ...
Very friendly, very reasonably priced, very honest if something’s broken or chipped. And overall great quality stuff. Will definitely come again!
Reviews from Google
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
If it's your first time, take a moment to explore each section thoroughly; you never know what treasures you might find.
Try visiting early in the week for a better selection, as the store is often stocked with new items.
Look for nearby parking to make your visit more convenient, and consider pairing your trip with a visit to other local shops or cafes.
Hours
- monday10:00 AM - 4:30 PM
- tuesday10:00 AM - 4:30 PM
- wednesday10:00 AM - 4:30 PM
- thursday10:00 AM - 4:30 PM
- friday10:00 AM - 3:30 PM
- saturdayClosed
- sunday10:00 AM - 3:30 PM