Second Chance Thrift Shop
Closed
About Second Chance Thrift Shop
Second Chance Thrift Shop is a charming thrift store located in Peapack and Gladstone, NJ, offering a delightful selection of secondhand goods. From unique decor items to clothing and household essentials, you'll find plenty of treasures waiting to be discovered.
The atmosphere here is warm and inviting, thanks in part to the friendly staff who create a positive shopping experience. Many visitors leave feeling uplifted, having not only found great items but also enjoyed the nice vibes of the shop.
Conveniently situated in the heart of Peapack and Gladstone, Second Chance Thrift Shop is easily accessible for anyone in the area. There's ample parking available, making it simple to stop by and explore what they have to offer.
Editor's Review
Second Chance Thrift Shop in Peapack and Gladstone, NJ, is truly a delightful find! With an impressive overall rating of 4.6 out of 5 from 38 reviews, it's no wonder that locals adore this charming store. Visitors consistently rave about the lovely atmosphere created by the warm and friendly staff. Jacqueline Meziani beautifully captures the essence of the shop, noting, "The best thing was the lovely staff." It’s clear that the welcoming vibe makes shopping here an uplifting experience.
What stands out even more is the well-organized layout and diverse array of items available. Carrie R. exclaimed, "Everything is very well organized and fairly priced," highlighting the exquisite decor items that would catch the eye of anyone decorating a new home. With treasures ranging from glassware to retro CDs, shoppers are bound to discover something special. Henry D. even mentioned that this store is a hidden gem, which speaks to its enchanting atmosphere that feels like a treasure hunt!
Customers also appreciate that the shop’s proceeds support programs for people with disabilities at Matheny, adding a wonderful layer of purpose to each purchase. As Iveth Mosquera noted, "A win-win for all!" This commitment to the community resonates well with shoppers. However, while there are many positives, the absence of electronics or gadgets might leave tech enthusiasts wanting more variety.
What We Like
- Friendly and helpful staff create a welcoming environment
- Well-organized with a unique variety of items
- Proceeds support community programs and services
Room for Improvement
- Limited selection of electronics or tech gadgets
- Some items may not be as new as others
What Customers Are Saying
“The best thing was the lovely staff.”
— Jacqueline Meziani
“Everything is very well organized and fairly priced.”
— Carrie R.
“This gem of a store... has a lot to offer.”
— Henry D.
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“A nice variety of items.”
“Everything is very well organized and fairly priced.”
“The ladies working there were incredibly kind.”
“Soak in the niceness vibes from the ladies.”
Insider Tips
Visit for a variety of gently used and new items.
Bring help for larger items as staff assist with carrying.
What to Expect
- Expect a friendly and helpful staff ready to assist you during your visit.
- You'll find a wide variety of secondhand goods, from clothing to home decor items, all organized for easy browsing.
- Prices are fair, making it a great spot for thrifty shoppers looking for quality items at a bargain.
Business Highlights
- ✓Family owned since 1992
- ✓Gently used donated items
- ✓Open all year
- ✓Volunteer-run shop
- ✓Donations accepted on Mondays
- ✓Unique one-of-a-kind items
Google Reviews
A nice variety of items. I got a couple of little treasures. The best thing was lovely staff. I recommend that if you’re ever feeling a little down, come here just to soak in the niceness vibes from the ladies who run the place.
Wow! This is such an incredible shop. Everything is very well organized and fairly priced. The decor items are exquisite. This is a wonderful place for anyone who is moving into a new home. The volunteers working here or very friendly and help me car...
super cool stuff, amazing prices and ladies at the counter were so super sweet!!
This gem of store hidden off of one of the small roads of Gladstone has a lot to offer. From glassware to old postcards to-- of course, clothes. There are no electonic gadgets or computers, but there are some nice movies and retro cd-rom PC games. Th...
They have lots of new items as well as very good gently used items. They're super friendly, and all of the proceeds go to programs and services for people with disabilities at Matheny. A win-win for all!
Reviews from Google
Specialties
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
If you're a first-time visitor, take your time to browse and enjoy the unique finds throughout the store.
Consider visiting on a Monday when they're open for a full day; Wednesdays are shorter and may have limited selections.
There's plenty of parking available, so you won't have to worry about finding a spot when you arrive.
Hours
- monday10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- tuesdayClosed
- wednesday10:00 AM - 3:00 PM
- thursdayClosed
- friday10:00 AM - 3:00 PM
- saturday10:00 AM - 2:00 PM
- sundayClosed