Mercer Island Thrift Shop
Closed
About Mercer Island Thrift Shop
Mercer Island Thrift Shop is a family-owned establishment that offers a variety of unique items, including arts and crafts, collectibles, and designer fashions. The store is dedicated to supporting local youth and family services, making every purchase meaningful.
The atmosphere at Mercer Island Thrift Shop is community-oriented and welcoming, though recent policies have affected customers' experiences. Many shoppers appreciate the unique finds available, but some have expressed discomfort with security measures.
Conveniently located on Mercer Island, the thrift shop is easily accessible and draws in both locals and visitors. With new inventory arriving every Tuesday, it's a great spot to check in regularly for fresh treasures.
Editor's Review
Mercer Island Thrift Shop has become a notable fixture on the island since its establishment in 1992, standing out for its commitment to supporting local youth and family services. Many reviewers appreciate the unique arts and crafts items and collectibles that are often found within its walls. The shop offers new inventory every Tuesday, which creates a sense of excitement among thrift shoppers eager to unearth hidden treasures. Still, recent customer feedback reveals that the store's reputation has taken a hit due to some new policies.
Several reviews express discomfort with the store's bag check policy, which some customers feel is overly stringent. Cora Bishop mentioned a particularly unpleasant experience, stating, "Her and another lady then told me that me and my 3-year-old grandson had to leave." Such incidents have contributed to a growing sentiment that the store's once friendly and welcoming atmosphere has diminished. Additionally, pricing has come under scrutiny, with Urban Peazant noting, "Another review mentioned it's like this place goes to the most expensive listing on eBay and that's the pricing." This suggests that while shoppers may be on the lookout for bargains, they might not always find them here.
What We Like
- Family-owned since 1992, fostering a community feel
- Supports local youth and family services, contributing to the community
- Unique arts and crafts items and collectibles available
- New inventory every Tuesday keeps the shopping experience fresh
Room for Improvement
- Strict bag check policy that many reviewers find uncomfortable
- Higher pricing compared to other thrift stores or online options
- Customer service experiences have been inconsistent and at times unfriendly
What Customers Are Saying
“This used to be a wonderful place to stop in when I was in town...”
— Cora Bishop
“Another review mentioned it's like this place goes to the most expensive listing on eBay...”
— Urban Peazant
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“Employees...start showing respect and kindness”
“You can’t carry your purse in the store”
“This place goes to the most expensive listing”
Insider Tips
Be prepared to check your bags at the door
Expect higher prices compared to other thrift stores
Thrift & Consignment Stores Details
What to Expect
- Expect a variety of unique items and collectibles that change with new inventory each week.
- You'll find a community-focused atmosphere, though be aware of the store's security policies.
- Prices are generally reasonable, and your purchases support local youth and family services.
Business Highlights
- ✓Family owned since 1992
- ✓Supports Mercer Island Youth and Family Services
- ✓Unique arts & crafts and collectibles available
- ✓Shipping via USPS available
- ✓New inventory every Tuesday
Google Reviews
This used to be a wonderful place to stop in when I was in town and get my thrift fix. They now have a policy where you can’t carry your purse in the store. On my last trip, the lady at the door told me I had to give her my purse and I expressed how ...
Unless the employees, and management start showing respect and kindness to their customers, apply their rules in a consistent way, (without prejudice, discrimination, harassment even), they will continue to loose paying and honest customers. After my...
I used to shop here but lately with new policy that they check bag, back bag make me feel uncomfortable. I wish they hire more security guards if they have been stolen items. Should not think any customer has potentially stolen your items.
I would never go there again. Me and my niece and her friend were stopped at the door and was asked to check our bags/purses at the door. I looked around and said really? Didn’t think nothing about it. Took my wallet and my phone out and gave the lad...
Another review mentioned it's like this place goes to the most expensive listing on eBay and that's the pricing. Which is pretty accurate. Thought I'd give it a try, and had a good look through and visit, but dang, could have stayed home and just sho...
Reviews from Google
Specialties
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
If you're a first-time visitor, consider going early in the week to get the best selection of new items.
Be prepared for the store's bag-checking policy, which may feel uncomfortable for some shoppers.
There's usually street parking available nearby, but be mindful of any parking restrictions in the area.
Hours
- monday10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
- tuesday10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
- wednesday10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
- thursday10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
- friday10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
- saturdayClosed
- sunday10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
