Pennywise Consignment Shop
Closed
About Pennywise Consignment Shop
Pennywise Consignment Shop in Stonington, CT, offers a wide selection of gently used clothing, shoes, and jewelry, making it a great spot for those looking to refresh their wardrobe without breaking the bank. With two floors full of items, shoppers can find everything from everyday wear to name-brand pieces, such as Lilly Pulitzer.
The atmosphere at Pennywise is lively and welcoming, often buzzing with fellow thrift enthusiasts. Customers frequently share their excitement about the great finds and affordable prices, making it a fun experience for the whole family.
Conveniently located in Stonington, Pennywise is easily accessible for locals and visitors alike. The shop's central location means you'll find plenty of parking options nearby, making your thrift shopping outing hassle-free.
Editor's Review
Pennywise Consignment Shop in Stonington, CT, is a treasure trove for anyone who loves designer clothing and accessories at reasonable prices. With an overall rating of 4.4/5 based on 176 reviews, it’s clear this family-owned shop, operating since 1988, has built a reputation for quality. Customers rave about the selection, and it’s no wonder: as Emily T. put it, it's 'jam-packed with excellent clothes at good prices.'
The store specializes in designer items, including handbags and jewelry, which has turned it into a go-to spot for fashion enthusiasts. Reviewers like Matthew S. appreciate the high-quality items available, emphasizing that even the smaller men's section is well curated, making it worth a visit. The friendly and helpful staff is another highlight; Jessica H. noted she found a gorgeous Chloe purse for an amazing price, thanks to their keen eye for quality.
However, it's not all sunshine and roses. Some reviewers pointed out the reduced size of the men's section, which could limit options for male shoppers. Additionally, while the store is organized and pleasant, the sheer volume of items might feel overwhelming for first-time visitors. Still, the consistent sales on colored tags provide a fun incentive to dig through the racks.
What We Like
- Excellent selection of designer clothing
- Friendly and helpful staff
- Good prices on high-quality items
Room for Improvement
- Smaller men's section
- Overwhelming inventory for first-time visitors
What Customers Are Saying
“'Jam-packed with excellent clothes at good prices.'”
— Emily Thompson
“'This store has the highest quality items of any thrifty store I frequent.'”
— Matthew Stuart
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“Highest quality items of any thrifty store”
“Amazing price for a gorgeous Chloe purse”
“Two floors full of clothing”
“Staff was friendly and helpful”
Insider Tips
Explore both floors for a wider variety
Look for sales on different colored tags
Thrift & Consignment Stores Details
Brands Carried
Current Specials
Sales on different colored tags
What to Expect
- Expect a friendly and enthusiastic atmosphere filled with fellow bargain hunters.
- You'll find a diverse selection of clothing, shoes, and accessories across two floors.
- Prices are reasonable, making it easy to find quality items without spending a lot.
Business Highlights
- ✓Family owned since 1988
- ✓Specializes in designer clothing and accessories
- ✓Open seven days a week
Google Reviews
Jam-packed with excellent clothes at good prices. While I was there a husband, wife and daughter were all trying on and rejoicing about the stock and the prices. The men's section is smaller than the women's but very well curated. Staff was friend...
This store has the highest quality items of any thrifty store I frequent. Prices are good too. They made the men's section a bit smaller but still an excellent selection.
Just Heard about Pennywise because I was looking for Lilly Pulitzer. I came in and they have a whole rack Lilly Pulitzer. Many other name brand clothing also. Two floors full of clothing. Prices aren't bad also. Lots to look at. Have a dressing room ...
Nice quality clothes, many new with tags. Very well organized. Wide variety of choices.
Wish I lived closer, I would have bought more! I got a gorgeous Chloe purse for an amazing price! They have sales on different colored tags. Great selection, and the pricing is consistent with consignment stores. I will definitely go again when I vis...
Reviews from Google
Specialties
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
Be sure to check both floors for the best selection of items.
Consider visiting on weekdays when it's typically less crowded.
There's plenty of parking nearby, so you won't have to worry about finding a spot.
Hours
- monday10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- tuesday10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- wednesday10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- thursday10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- friday10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- saturday10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- sunday10:00 AM - 5:00 PM