Agrace Thrift Store | Madison West

Closed
Est. 1992
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…Β½4.6
Agrace Thrift Store | Madison West in Madison, WI

About Agrace Thrift Store | Madison West

Agrace Thrift Store in Madison West offers a fantastic selection of secondhand goods, including clothing, furniture, home goods, and shoes. Whether you're looking for that perfect outfit or unique decor for your home, you’re likely to find something special here.

The store has a welcoming atmosphere, praised for its cleanliness and organization. Items are arranged neatly, with clothing often color-coordinated, making the shopping experience enjoyable and easy.

Conveniently located in Madison, this thrift store is accessible and easy to find. It’s a great stop for anyone in the area, whether you're a local or just passing through.

Editor's Review

Stepping into Agrace Thrift Store in Madison, WI, feels a bit like stumbling upon a treasure chest. Shoppers rave about the cleanliness and organization of the store, where items are even color-coordinated for an easy browsing experience. Lisa Kraft, a delighted customer, exclaimed, "WOW! This shop is the best thrift store in town, or of any I have gone to." Such praise sets the stage for a shopping experience that's both enjoyable and fruitful.

Many reviews highlight the store's diverse inventory, which changes weekly. This keeps regulars coming back, eager to see what's new. Rosalee Fillion stumbled upon Agrace while in town for a volleyball tournament and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of clothes and unique household items, noting, "Good quality clothes, not for teeny boppers, and lots of cute household items arranged very tastefully."

However, not everything is perfect at this thrift store. A few reviewers, like Jenny, mentioned the cramped quarters within the shop, leading to moments of discomfort while browsing. Her experience, while generally positive, had a touch of frustration as interactions with staff sometimes felt a bit rushed. The cozy atmosphere can feel a bit too snug during busy hours, which is something potential shoppers should keep in mind.

Despite a few complaints, the overwhelming consensus is that Agrace Thrift Store offers an enjoyable shopping experience with friendly staff and a focus on supporting a worthy cause. Many visitors even seek out its multiple locations, as Kelly Daugherty noted, "Sales support a worthy cause. I encourage you to check it out." This sense of community spirit combined with quality finds makes Agrace a noteworthy stop for both locals and visitors alike.

Best for: Bargain hunters and families looking for quality thrift items.

What We Like

  • Clean and well-organized environment
  • Diverse and quality inventory that changes weekly
  • Friendly and helpful staff

Room for Improvement

  • Cramped space during peak hours
  • Some felt staff interactions could be improved

What Customers Are Saying

β€œWOW! This shop is the best thrift store in town, or of any I have gone to.”

β€” Lisa Kraft

β€œGood quality clothes, not for teeny boppers, and lots of cute household items arranged very tastefully.”

β€” Rosalee Fillion

What Shoppers Say

Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews

CleanlinessGood

β€œIt's clean, organized, easy to shop.”

SelectionGood

β€œLots of cool little things in here.”

PricesExcellent

β€œPrices reasonable as well!”

StaffMixed

β€œMy interactions with the staff were okay.”

AtmosphereMixed

β€œIt felt really cramped in there.”

Best for: Thrift shoppers seeking quality items at great prices.

Insider Tips

Visit on weekdays for a less crowded experience.

Look for color-coordinated clothing for easy shopping.

Thrift & Consignment Stores Details

EBT / SNAP Accepted

Certifications

SNAP/EBT Accepted

What to Expect

  • Expect a clean and organized shopping environment that makes it easy to browse.
  • You'll find a diverse selection of quality secondhand items suitable for all ages.
  • Prices are generally affordable, making it a great place to score bargains on gently used goods.

Business Highlights

  • βœ“Family owned since 1992
  • βœ“Accepts EBT/SNAP
  • βœ“New inventory every Tuesday
  • βœ“Thrifty Thursdays with special sales
  • βœ“Gift cards available
  • βœ“Delivery available for purchases
  • βœ“Volunteer opportunities available

Google Reviews

Lisa Kraft
Lisa Kraft2 years ago
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

WOW! This shop is the best thrift store in town, or of any I have gone to. It's clean, organized, easy to shop. The clothes are color coordinated! I scored some great magenta velvet pants, Lands End cardigans. Ahh, so awesome!

Rosalee Fillion
Rosalee Fillion7 months ago
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

What a sweet little surprise! Out here in Wisconsin for a volleyball tournament, and stumbled across this store. Good quality clothes, not for teeny boppers, and lots of cute household items arranged very tastefully. Prices reasonable as well! Great ...

Suettle Sweetroll (The Worsted Witch)
Suettle Sweetroll (The Worsted Witch)9 months ago
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

One of the best thrift stores I've ever been to! We were there to shop for my daughter for her new apartment and she found several great bargains. It was so hard to restrain myself and not buy a law for myself! Reasonably priced vintage, craft suppli...

Jenny
Jenny10 months ago
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜†

This is a neat little store. I walked in on a weekday, and it was packed. They've got lots of cool little things in here. I just wish it was a little bit bigger of a space because it felt really cramped in there. My interactions with the staff were ...

Kelly Daugherty
Kelly Daugherty8 months ago
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

Clean, well-organized store with extremely friendly staff. We enjoyed our visit there so much that we sought out the two other Agrace Thrift Store locations while we were visiting from Pennsylvania. Sales support a worthy cause. I encourage you to...

Reviews from Google

Specialties

FurnitureHome dΓ©corClothingCollectibles

Payment Methods

CashCredit/DebitEBT/SNAP

Frequently Asked Questions

Visiting Tips

If you're a first-time visitor, take your time to explore the different sections of the store.

Visiting during the week might mean fewer crowds, giving you a more relaxed shopping experience.

There’s typically parking available nearby, but consider carpooling or using public transport if you're visiting during peak times.

Hours

  • monday10:00β€―AM - 5:00β€―PM
  • tuesday10:00β€―AM - 5:00β€―PM
  • wednesday10:00β€―AM - 5:00β€―PM
  • thursday10:00β€―AM - 5:00β€―PM
  • friday10:00β€―AM - 5:00β€―PM
  • saturday10:00β€―AM - 5:00β€―PM
  • sundayClosed

Want your business to appear here? Learn how to advertise

Customer Reviews

Agrace Thrift Store | Madison West -... | Thrift Store Pal