Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store
Closed
About Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store
The Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store in Madison, WI, offers a variety of secondhand items, including clothing, home goods, and unique finds. Every purchase helps support the local humane society, making it a worthwhile stop for thrift shoppers.
You'll find the store well-stocked and organized, creating a pleasant shopping atmosphere. The friendly staff are always ready to assist, ensuring you have a positive experience while browsing their selection.
Conveniently located in Madison, the store is easily accessible and has ample parking nearby. Whether you're a local or just visiting, it’s a great spot to find quality secondhand goods.
Editor's Review
The Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store in Madison, WI, boasts an impressive overall rating of 4.6 out of 5 based on 121 reviews. This family-owned establishment, operating since 1992, stands out for its commitment to supporting both people and animals in need. As Cynthia Albrecht succinctly put it, "Shop here first for unusual pet needs... No need to spend full price when good quality used items are available for a low price." The store's diverse inventory of over 20,000 unique items combined with new arrivals every Tuesday makes it a treasure trove for bargain hunters.
However, not all feedback is glowing. Some customers, like Melisa Husic, expressed disappointment with specific purchases, stating, "I bought a vase full of jewelry for $28, and more than half of the items were broken." Another reviewer, Chris Wall, highlighted concerns about the store's selection, remarking on problematic items that contradicted their stated values regarding equality. Such comments indicate that while the store excels in affordability and variety, attention to quality control and inventory choices could be improved.
What We Like
- Wide variety of items available, including unique pet supplies
- Affordably priced with a customer rewards program
- Friendly and dedicated volunteer staff
Room for Improvement
- Inconsistent quality of items in stock
- Occasional inappropriate inventory choices
What Customers Are Saying
“I love this store and all the staff. Great job.”
— Drew
“The prices are amazing and most everything I saw was worth every penny.”
— Drew
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“more than half of the items were broken”
“The prices are amazing and most everything I saw”
“The volunteer staff are absolutely amazing”
“I was surprised by the large amount of pet supplies”
Insider Tips
Check items carefully for damage before purchase
Explore pet supplies for unique finds
Consider visiting during weekdays for a quieter experience
Thrift & Consignment Stores Details
What to Expect
- Expect a clean and organized shopping environment with a wide variety of items to choose from.
- You'll come across everything from clothing to household goods, making it a fun place to explore.
- Prices are generally low, offering great value for secondhand items that support a good cause.
Business Highlights
- ✓Two locations in Madison
- ✓Supports the Dane County Humane Society's mission
- ✓Opened on January 19, 2019
- ✓Thrift Store East opened in July 2024
- ✓Offers more than 20,000 unique items
- ✓Community success story
- ✓Revenue supports animal care and adoption
Google Reviews
I was really disappointed with my purchase at this thrift store. I bought a vase full of jewelry for $28, and more than half of the items were broken, missing pieces, or basically unusable. I get that it’s a thrift store, but for $28, I expected bett...
I've only been in this store twice, and will never come again. The first time I came in, around Christmas, I found a CD "Music of the Luftwaffe". I turned it in to an employee. Today I found a book glorifying the Confederacy. I handed it in to a cash...
The store is well stocked , organized and staffed. The prices are amazing and most everything I saw was worth every penny. I love this store and all the staff. Great job . (They also follow all safety guidelines that allows us to shop in comfort and...
I was surprised by the large amount of pet supplies they have. Shop here first for unusual pet needs like steps to get up to higher surfaces, a cooling mat, cat tree, gates, dog life vest, and snow booties in various sizes. Also a wide selection of ...
Best thrift store in town along with their East side location. It isn't the biggest store, but you're bound to find something! They have affordable fair pricing and offer a rewards card. Most thrifts do not offer rewards anymore, so it's a little mor...
Reviews from Google
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
If you're a first-time visitor, take your time to browse the aisles as new items come in regularly.
Consider visiting on a Tuesday or Wednesday when the store is open later, allowing for a more relaxed shopping experience.
Look for nearby cafes or parks to enjoy after your shopping trip, and don't forget to check for parking options close to the store.
Hours
- monday11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- tuesday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- wednesday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- thursday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- friday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- saturday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- sunday11:00 AM - 5:00 PM