Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store
Closed
About Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store
Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store offers a wide variety of unique items, from clothing to home decor, all donated to support the humane society's mission. With new inventory added regularly, shoppers can find treasures while helping local animals in need.
The store has a welcoming and organized atmosphere, making it easy to browse through the extensive selection. You'll find friendly staff ready to assist you, ensuring a pleasant shopping experience.
Located in Madison, WI, the thrift store is easily accessible for both locals and visitors. With two locations, shoppers have the convenience of choosing the one that best fits their route.
Editor's Review
The Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store in Madison, WI, boasts an impressive overall rating of 4.6 out of 5 based on 123 reviews, highlighting its strong community presence and support for animal welfare. Opened in January 2019 and expanding with a second location in July 2024, this store offers over 20,000 unique items. Reviewers consistently praise the affordability and organization of the store. As Drew noted, "The store is well stocked, organized and staffed. The prices are amazing and most everything I saw was worth every penny." Additionally, the store's mission of supporting the Dane County Humane Society resonates with many customers, creating a sense of community spirit.
However, not all experiences are positive. Some customers express dissatisfaction with specific items. Melisa Husic shared her disappointment with a vase of jewelry, saying, "more than half of the items were broken, missing pieces, or basically unusable." Another review from Chris Wall raised concerns about the store's product selection, mentioning finding a book glorifying the Confederacy, which contrasts with the store's stated values. These critiques suggest that while many appreciate the store’s mission, there may be inconsistencies in the quality and appropriateness of items available.
What We Like
- Affordable prices and well-organized displays
- Strong community support for animal welfare
- Friendly and dedicated volunteer staff
Room for Improvement
- Inconsistent quality of merchandise
- Concerns about item appropriateness
What Customers Are Saying
“The store is well stocked, organized and staffed. The prices are amazing and most everything I saw was worth every penny.”
— Drew
“I get that it’s a thrift store, but for $28, I expected better.”
— Melisa Husic
Thrift & Consignment Stores Details
What to Expect
- Expect a well-stocked and organized store that makes shopping enjoyable.
- You'll find over 20,000 unique items, each with its own story waiting to be discovered.
- Prices are reasonable, and many items are worth every penny, offering great value for your money.
Business Highlights
- ✓Family owned since 1992
- ✓Supports the important work of helping people and animals
- ✓Two locations in Madison
- ✓Offers over 20,000 unique items
- ✓New inventory every week
- ✓Community success story since 2019
Google Reviews
I was really disappointed with my purchase at this thrift store. I bought a vase full of jewelry for $28, and more than half of the items were broken, missing pieces, or basically unusable. I get that it’s a thrift store, but for $28, I expected bett...
I've only been in this store twice, and will never come again. The first time I came in, around Christmas, I found a CD "Music of the Luftwaffe". I turned it in to an employee. Today I found a book glorifying the Confederacy. I handed it in to a cash...
The store is well stocked , organized and staffed. The prices are amazing and most everything I saw was worth every penny. I love this store and all the staff. Great job . (They also follow all safety guidelines that allows us to shop in comfort and...
I was surprised by the large amount of pet supplies they have. Shop here first for unusual pet needs like steps to get up to higher surfaces, a cooling mat, cat tree, gates, dog life vest, and snow booties in various sizes. Also a wide selection of ...
Best thrift store in town along with their East side location. It isn't the biggest store, but you're bound to find something! They have affordable fair pricing and offer a rewards card. Most thrifts do not offer rewards anymore, so it's a little mor...
Reviews from Google
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
Don't hesitate to ask staff for assistance or recommendations—they're friendly and knowledgeable.
Try to visit during the week when it's less crowded for a more relaxed shopping experience.
Check for nearby parking options or other shops in the area to make the most of your visit.
Hours
- monday11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- tuesday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- wednesday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- thursday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- friday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- saturday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- sunday11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
