Finders Keepers Thrift Store

Closed
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜†4.2
Finders Keepers Thrift Store in Buffalo, WY

About Finders Keepers Thrift Store

Finders Keepers Thrift Store in Buffalo, WY offers a variety of secondhand items, from clothing to household goods, making it a great spot for those looking to find unique treasures. With a friendly atmosphere and a commitment to quality, it's a place where you can shop while supporting a good cause.

The store has a clean and organized layout, making it easy to browse through different sections. Customers have noted the friendly staff, who are always ready to help you find what you need, contributing to a pleasant shopping experience.

Located in the heart of Buffalo, Finders Keepers is easily accessible for both locals and visitors. Whether you’re on a road trip or just exploring the area, it's a convenient stop to find great bargains.

Editor's Review

Finders Keepers Thrift Store in Buffalo, WY, has garnered a solid reputation among locals and travelers alike. Many reviews highlight the store's cleanliness and organization, making it a pleasant shopping experience. As Kayla Belgiano noted, it’s 'literally the best thrift store I've ever been to,' which is quite the endorsement considering her cross-country thrift expedition. The friendly staff also receive praise, contributing to a warm atmosphere that invites repeat visits. Customers appreciate the variety available, with reviews mentioning everything from gently used clothing to household items.

A standout feature is their commitment to the community; proceeds from the store benefit the local Senior Center, which gives shoppers a sense of purpose with their purchases. Sapphire904 emphasized this aspect, stating, 'I like that the proceeds go to the Senior Center. It's a good way to keep funds in the local community.' However, there are a few quirks to consider. A less enthusiastic review mentioned that sometimes, the inventory can be hit or miss. Shanz Anz succinctly expressed frustration by saying, 'No finders keepers doesn’t work because it’s mine,' which hints at a playful misunderstanding of the store's name.

Best for: This store is best for budget-conscious shoppers looking for a variety of gently used items while supporting a good cause.

What We Like

  • Clean and organized shopping environment
  • Friendly and helpful staff
  • Great selection of items
  • Community-focused with proceeds supporting the Senior Center

Room for Improvement

  • Inventory can be inconsistent
  • Occasional frustration over item availability

What Customers Are Saying

β€œWe were stranded in Buffalo due to car problems... a kind employee came up to me and someone had just donated 2 towels!”

β€” Jim Kunkle

β€œGreat thrift store. They have a little bit of everything and I always find something I need when I go in.”

β€” sapphire904

What Shoppers Say

Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews

SelectionGood

β€œThey have a little bit of everything”

PricesExcellent

β€œAMAZING prices. 1/2 off everything on Thursdays!”

StaffGood

β€œThe staff are very friendly”

CleanlinessGood

β€œIt's clean and organized very well”

Best for: Thrift shoppers seeking great deals and friendly service

Insider Tips

Visit on Thursdays for 1/2 off everything

Shop mid-week for better selection

What to Expect

  • You can expect a friendly shopping environment with helpful staff ready to assist you.
  • The selection includes various secondhand items, so you're likely to find something that catches your eye.
  • Pricing is generally affordable, making it a great option for budget-conscious shoppers.

Google Reviews

Jim Kunkle
Jim Kunkle2 years ago
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

We were stranded in Buffalo due to car problems. Went there in search of towels and a blanket. Unfortunately when I arrived someone had just bought all the towels. But, while shopping to find a blanket, the very kind employee came up to me and someon...

shanz anz
shanz anz3 months ago
β˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†

No finders keepers doesnt work becuase its mine

sapphire904
sapphire9044 years ago
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

Great thrift store. They have a little bit of everything and I always find something I need when I go in. It's clean and organized very well. The staff are very friendly and I like that the proceeds go to the Senior Center. It's a good way to keep fu...

Kayla Belgiano
Kayla Belgiano3 years ago
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

Literally the best thrift store I've ever been to.... And I've been on a cross country thrift extravaganza, so it's saying a lot!! Good cause, great finds, AMAZING prices. 1/2 off everything on Thursdays!!

JESSE HARRIS
JESSE HARRIS7 years ago
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

Great selection of gently used items, friendly service and a comfortable shopping experience. Items are in good to new condition and are priced to be easy on your wallet and that's what makes you want to come back!

Reviews from Google

Frequently Asked Questions

Visiting Tips

If it's your first time, take your time to browse the different sections to fully appreciate the variety of items available.

Wednesday mornings might be a good time to visit, as you may find freshly stocked items.

Look for nearby parking options to make your visit easier, especially if the store gets busy.

Hours

  • mondayClosed
  • tuesdayClosed
  • wednesday10:00β€―AM - 2:00β€―PM
  • thursday10:00β€―AM - 5:00β€―PM
  • friday10:00β€―AM - 5:00β€―PM
  • saturday10:00β€―AM - 4:00β€―PM
  • sundayClosed

Want your business to appear here? Learn how to advertise

Customer Reviews