Bargain Garden
Closed
About Bargain Garden
Bargain Garden is a thrift shop that offers a wide variety of second-hand items to the community, all while supporting Fox Valley Lutheran High School's teen ministry and other charities. You can find everything from clothing to household goods, making it a great spot for thrift enthusiasts.
The atmosphere at Bargain Garden is warm and inviting, with a friendly staff ready to help you find exactly what you're looking for. It's a small shop, but it feels personal and is packed with unique treasures waiting to be discovered.
Located in Appleton, WI, Bargain Garden is easily accessible and is a convenient stop for locals and visitors alike. With its community-focused mission, it’s a place where you can shop with purpose.
Editor's Review
Bargain Garden, nestled in the heart of Appleton, WI, is not just any thrift shop; it’s a community gem that combines a rich variety of items with a mission to support local charities. With an impressive rating of 4.6 out of 5 from 75 reviews, it’s clear that many locals adore this place. As Elizabeth Martzahl put it, 'Bargain Garden will always be one of my favorite thrift stores.' You can feel the warm atmosphere as soon as you step through the door, greeted by friendly staff eager to help you find that perfect treasure.
Despite its small size, the shop manages to pack in a delightful selection of clothing and thrift items that keep customers coming back for more. You might even find some unique pieces at prices that can’t be beat! Allyce Zimmer raved about a recent 25% off sale, saying, 'Wonderful store. Profits go to Fox Valley Lutheran. Great prices. Fun sales.' However, not everyone is singing the same tune. A few reviews noted that some prices felt a bit high, with Cindy B. expressing disappointment over her donated item being sold for over $100, saying, 'This seems very high for a secondhand store that relies on donations.'
Still, the overall experience at Bargain Garden shines through. It’s a place where shoppers can feel good about their purchases while giving back to the community, making it a worthwhile stop for anyone looking to score some great deals!
What We Like
- Community-focused mission supporting local charities
- Friendly and helpful staff
- Wide variety of thrift items and clothing
Room for Improvement
- Some items are priced higher than expected
- Limited selection compared to larger thrift stores
What Customers Are Saying
“Bargain Garden will always be one of my favorite thrift stores.”
— Elizabeth Martzahl
“Wonderful store. Profits go to Fox Valley Lutheran. Great prices. Fun sales.”
— Allyce Zimmer
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“Some items are on the higher side”
“They have one of my favorite clothing selections”
“The staff is super nice”
“Profits go to Fox Valley Lutheran”
Insider Tips
Look for sales — they offer discounts on everything
Check for higher-priced items and compare with original value
Thrift & Consignment Stores Details
Current Specials
25% off everything
What to Expect
- You'll enjoy a friendly shopping experience with helpful staff.
- Expect a diverse selection of thrift items that rotate frequently.
- Prices are reasonable, making it a great place to find bargains.
Business Highlights
- ✓Supports Fox Valley Lutheran High School's teen ministry
- ✓Donations accepted
- ✓Thrift shop with featured bargains
Google Reviews
I’ve donated items to this store in the past because it’s a local business I wanted to support. However, I was very surprised and disappointed by what I recently saw. One of the items I donated—a tray with glass bottles that I originally paid a total...
Bargin Garden will always be one of my favorite thrift stores. It's small in the best ways, and they have one of my favorite clothing selections in a thrift store just about ever. The staff is super nice, and the money they make goes to a good cause.
Great place to shop and great prices along with exceptional staff
Wonderful store. Profits go to Fox Valley Lutheran. Great prices. Fun sales. Today we bought so much. I will attach two photos. The sale was 25% off everything!
Good small store. Not a huge selection of clothing but their prices on kids clothes are better than Goodwill. Decent prices overall. Some items are on the higher side because the store knows they have a more valuable item. Did used to be cheaper in t...
Reviews from Google
Specialties
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
If you're visiting for the first time, take your time to browse; you never know what treasures you'll find.
Try to arrive early in the week for the best selection, as new items come in regularly.
There's plenty of parking available nearby, so you won't have to worry about finding a spot.
Hours
- monday9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
- tuesday9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
- wednesday9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
- thursday9:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- friday9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
- saturday9:00 AM - 12:00 PM
- sundayClosed
