Elite Repeat Consignment Shop
Closed
About Elite Repeat Consignment Shop
Elite Repeat Consignment Shop is a popular spot in Brookfield, WI, specializing in a curated selection of secondhand clothing and accessories. Shoppers can find unique pieces at affordable prices, making it a go-to destination for thrift lovers.
The atmosphere at Elite Repeat is a mixed bag according to reviews, with some praising the fantastic customer service while others feel the staff could be more attentive. Despite the varied experiences, many visitors appreciate the charm and character that comes with shopping in a consignment store.
Located conveniently in Brookfield, this shop is easily accessible for locals and visitors alike. There’s ample parking nearby, making it simple to pop in and browse the latest finds.
Editor's Review
Walking into Elite Repeat Consignment Shop in Brookfield, WI, is like stepping into a treasure trove brimming with stylish finds. Many customers rave about the 'amazing selection' and the 'fantastic customer service,' with Annette Caraulia noting that she appreciates the quality of clothing and accessories available, from workout gear to formal attire. The store has been a family-owned gem since 1989, and its charm lies not just in its upscale offerings but also in the unique pieces that seem to call out from the racks.
However, not all experiences have been positive. Some reviewers express frustration over the strict consignment policy, with Barb McCormick sharing her disappointment about needing 15 items to even be considered for consignment. Those seeking to sell may find the process a bit daunting, as Megan Stuart noted in her review about a disheartening appointment experience. Yet, it’s clear that many customers love the variety and quality available, leading to a mixed bag of reviews overall.
What We Like
- Diverse selection of upscale clothing and accessories
- Friendly and helpful staff for in-store shopping
- Loyalty points program for regular customers
Room for Improvement
- Strict consignment policy requiring 15 items or more
- Inconsistent customer service experiences
What Customers Are Saying
“Amazing selection and fantastic customer service!!! A favorite store of mine for sure!”
— Shana Weber
“I appreciate the quality of the selection of clothing, jewelry, shoes, and accessories.”
— Annette Caraulia
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“They seem about as Snotty as they can be.”
“I appreciate the quality of the selection.”
“Amazing selection and fantastic customer service!!!”
“Unless you have 15 or more items... do not bother.”
Insider Tips
Bring at least 15 items for selling.
Visit during less busy hours for better service.
Thrift & Consignment Stores Details
What to Expect
- You might experience mixed levels of customer service, so be prepared for varying interactions.
- The shop features a unique collection of secondhand clothing, which can change frequently, so every visit may offer something new.
- Prices are generally affordable, making it a great place for budget-conscious shoppers looking for quality items.
Business Highlights
- ✓Family owned since 1989
- ✓Upscale consignment boutique
- ✓Offers fashion, integrity, low costs
- ✓Consignment by appointment only
- ✓Shop for special occasions or daily wear
- ✓Unique finds for gifts
Google Reviews
It seems every time I go in there.The people are not the least bit interested in helping me. They don't tell you about the sales.They sit and chat with They're friends. They seem about as Snotty as they can be. They can bite me
Amazing selection and fantastic customer service!!! A favorite store of mine for sure!
SO frustrated. Unless you have 15 or more items of clothing do not bother going here. I have 5 items from Faye’s in Mequon, expensive, never worn, I’m sure would be quick sales but a worker told me unless I have 15 items or more they don’t want them...
I have been shopping at Elite Repeat for many years and always have a good experience. I appreciate the quality of the selection of clothing, jewelry, shoes, and accessories. They have every type of women's clothing from workout to formal attire - ...
I would give 0 stars if possible. Called and scheduled an appointment to bring in a ton of clothes for 10:30 on a Saturday. When we got there a lady opened the door and rudely said we don't open until 11. We told her we scheduled an appointment and s...
Reviews from Google
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
If it's your first time, take your time to browse as the inventory can vary greatly from visit to visit.
Consider visiting during the week for a quieter shopping experience, especially on Tuesday or Wednesday.
Check out nearby shops in Brookfield after your visit, as there's often a variety of stores and restaurants to explore.
Hours
- mondayClosed
- tuesday10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
- wednesday10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
- thursday10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
- friday10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
- saturday10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- sundayClosed